Canaries in the Mines
The last couple of days have been really hard…not only we are witnessing violence and aggressions in the Palestinian territories. But we have to shut up and tone it down in asking sorry begging for the release of our prisoners…In the Middle East it is called “blame the victim” and follow what the rulers want. Rulers now want us Syrians to intervene in Lebanese politics and campaign for Aoun/Nasrallah to assume power in Lebanon. Rulers are saying Michel Kilo was doing exactly the right thing until he exercised his right to express his solidarity with the Lebanese demands, he should not done that. He was too confrontational!
Meanwhile some people who I was impressed with and thought that they are trying to change things, reverted back and repositioned themselves to be close to the Syrian regime positions (after they got all the signals loud and clear about the regime strategy) because it is better than doing nothing. As someone told them “you said earlier putting Michel Kilo in prison is wrong, now you are trying to finesse your position, by blaming the problem partially on his (Kilo) outspoken remarks at such a critical time for our nation and at being misrepresented by journalists. Someone else commented “What a waste, I see so many talented personalities, being misused by this awful regime”
Zenobia a fellow participant in the debate wrote this magnificent comment with a story:I believe as you - with no reservations at all- that we have to protect the voice of dissent. We need to listen to our metaphoric canaries.For anyone not familiar, an old American linguistic usage refers to those who are our “canaries in the mines”. This refers to the habit of miners who historically used canaries to take down into the mines. If the mines became too toxically full of carbon monoxide, the canaries would begin to sing! (or I suppose fall over dead) as a sign that the miners were in mortal danger. Regardless, if people make wrong decisions, we must, for certain, protect those who are our canaries, and never imprison them for singing out.
Here are some relevant defense comments that I made in no particular order during the heated debate on Odds and Ends
-
In that same interview of Al hayat, Bashar said regarding the arrests: “We warned them and This is an internal matter, no one tells us what to do!” who is he :GOD!!!!!!!! the Syrian people were not created by him and don’t owe him anything…His diapers were being changed when Michel Kilo started writing!
-
All what Bashar is capable and wants to do in terms of reform is listen to the Austrian opera performs in Damascus…but he does not mind inflaming the people at the mosques with security-Mukhabarat people like Abu Ka3ka3, or burning embassies in Damascus or becoming an ayatullah himself…in the process becoming a toy in Iran’s hand, promoting Islamic forces like Hamas and Hizbullah, and weakening up all secular national people in the middle east.
-
Lebanon is our only remaining window and all you do is justify Syria’s position in making it an enemy.
-
You are hoping to get something from the regime (reform wise) but they are playing you and you know that but you have no alternative but to blame the victim.
-
Your strategy of leaning on people that you can lean on and not tell the regime or the other side what they ought to do won’t work for that long. Specially when I see not even a 2 percent budging…where are the results of working with the regime???
-
There is a minimum acceptable and it is not democracy, it is called human respect. When they start treating people with respect and dignity then the country will move forward.
-
It does not matter how much money gets pumped into the country and the corrupted pockets, that won’t advance the country. You can decorate a tomb with so much gold and luxury but it is still a tomb with dead people in it.
-
Can you ask yourself one second what does the regime lose by releasing Kilo and the others arrested recently (well 45-50 days now)…then ask yourself why don’t they do it (free them). The conclusion is they want to humiliate us and have their boots on our necks. It is called suffocating Syria and Lebanon. Once they start playing nice and show us that they intend to rule in a more civilized way then as far as I am concerned they can stay.
-
So in other words, Michel kilo will be free when the whole Middle East problem will be solved…great let’s prepare for his funeral in jail because I don’t see that happening pretty soon.
-
Again what does it matter who rules Lebanon with Kilo being in Jail, I don’t see the relation, Michel Kilo is not Lebanese and he did not ally himself with anyone, he was just saying let’s open a new page.
-
So from now on Syria will be friendly with Lebanon when the leader is a little puppet in their hand … Last time I checked Lebanon is not a province like Aleppo or Tartous, it is an independent state…
-
Again Michel Kilo does not belong in Jail, regardless of what is happening in
Lebanon or Syria or the opposition -
The Hypocrisy here is what does Syria achieve by confronting the US and the West, what does the US want from Syria? How come a lot of countries who made up with the west advance and have a lot of individual freedoms (look at Puerto Rico/Dominican republic for example and compare them to Cuba, or compare Poland versus Belarus) and people/countries who call for confrontation end up being oppressed by their rulers.
-
Thank you for deciding for the Syrian people that they can’t afford and don’t want democracy…I bet similar Romanian people decided that during Ceausescu, and Chileans during Pinochet…the list is long. Eastern Europe and South America made so much progress the last 15 years, Asia made so much money during the same time and we are still debating whether it is right or wrong for someone to be put in Prison.
-
Learn from Serbia and Montenegro who just few years ago were hellishly bombed by the US planes and now they are ready to open a new page. I am not not advocating violence here, but I am stating how the people are ready to overlook the past for a better future.
-
Not all Americans are behind their presidents who keep telling them they are in danger, why do all Syrians have to follow blindly their leaders that got them nowhere…
But people made up their minds however and no one will be convinced… the Syrian regime apparently got big boost of Solidarity from other Arab rulers regarding the Israeli planes visit to Assad’s palace. The regime strives on incidents like that and its popularity rating will sky rocket just like it did for Bush after Sept 11. I can now imagine a whole circus going on in Syria, even probably the prisoners must issue an ironic show of support for the regime…there is no justice in the middle east, people need dictators to feel safe!!! And it is not healthy for the canaries to exist or survive there.
4 comments June 30, 2006